Annotated Bibliography on the Green Man and Sheela-na-gig
These studies together provide a layered understanding of the Green Man and Sheela-na-gig:
• as artistic motifs;
• as cultural survivals bridging paganism and Christianity;
• as archetypes of wildness, fertility, and threat;
• and as mirrors of the collective human relationship with nature and the body.
Green Man Studies
The Green Man – William Anderson (1990)
A richly illustrated exploration of the Green Man in medieval and modern art and architecture. Anderson connects the Green Man to ancient pagan traditions, discussing his symbolism as a figure of fertility, renewal, and the untamed spirit of nature surviving within Christian stonework.
The Green Man: The Archetype of Our Oneness with the Earth – Clive Hicks (2000)
Hicks examines the Green Man as an ecological archetype, arguing that the image embodies humanity’s forgotten unity with the natural world. He contextualizes the Green Man within modern environmental thought and spiritual ecology.
The Foliate Head: An Iconographic and Historical Study – Lady Raglan (1939, journal article)
A seminal article that popularized the term “Green Man” and framed the foliate head as a survivance of ancient nature worship. Raglan’s work is foundational in modern Green Man studies, though later scholarship has refined her claims.
The Green Man in Church Architecture – Kathleen Basford (1978)
A detailed survey of Green Man carvings in British ecclesiastical architecture, exploring regional variations and hypothesizing why this pagan figure persisted in Christian sacred spaces.
The Green Man and the Dragon: A Short History of an Archetype – John Matthews (2002)
Matthews expands the Green Man beyond Britain, comparing him to parallel figures in European and Asian folklore, and exploring the interplay between creative and destructive aspects of the wild masculine.
Sheela-na-gig Studies
Sheela-na-gigs: Unravelling an Enigma – Barbara Freitag (2004)
A comprehensive academic study combining folklore, art history, and feminist theory. Freitag examines Sheela-na-gigs as symbols of fertility, protection, and subversion, and explores debates over whether they reflect pagan survivals or medieval Christian morality.
The Sheela-na-gigs of Ireland and Britain: The Divine Hag of the Christian Celts – Jack Roberts (2005)
Roberts offers a detailed catalogue of Sheela-na-gig carvings, contextualized within Celtic goddess traditions. He interprets them as remnants of a divine hag or crone figure representing sovereignty, life, and death.
Sheela-na-gig: The Dark Goddess of Sacred Power – Starr Goode (2016)
Goode’s book presents Sheela-na-gig as an archetypal Dark Goddess, exploring her significance in art, feminism, and spiritual practice. She argues the figure embodies sacred sexuality and the raw power of creation and destruction.
The Sheela-na-gig – Joanne McMahon & Jack Roberts (2001)
An accessible photographic guide documenting over a hundred Sheela-na-gigs in Ireland, with commentary on their placement, stylistic features, and cultural meanings.
Sheela-na-gigs: Origins and Functions – James Jerman and Anthony Weir (1986)
A critical examination of Sheela-na-gigs within medieval architecture, questioning earlier theories of pagan survival and considering their potential role as warnings against lust or as apotropaic figures.
Comparative Annotated Bibliography: Overlaps Between the Green Man and Sheela-na-gig
The Sheela-na-gigs of Ireland and Britain: The Divine Hag of the Christian Celts – Jack Roberts (2005)
Roberts draws parallels between the Sheela-na-gig and other vegetative and fertility symbols, including the Green Man. He suggests both figures function as protective, apotropaic images at thresholds and carry a dual creative-destructive charge tied to natural cycles.
The Green Man – William Anderson (1990)
While focusing primarily on the Green Man, Anderson devotes sections to comparing him with the Sheela-na-gig as survivals of pre-Christian nature deities representing male and female principles of fertility and threat. He situates both as mediators between untamed nature and human-built sacred space.
Sheela-na-gigs: Unravelling an Enigma – Barbara Freitag (2004)
Freitag references the Green Man as a male counterpart in discussions of medieval folk survivals and fertility motifs. She considers how both figures reflect human ambivalence toward sexuality, wildness, and the tension between fear and veneration.
The Foliate Head: An Iconographic and Historical Study – Lady Raglan (1939, article)
This foundational work introduces the Green Man in the context of broader nature symbolism and notes links to female fertility figures, including Sheela-na-gig-like images, to argue for a shared pagan heritage of vegetative and sexual symbolism.
The Green Man and the Dragon: A Short History of an Archetype – John Matthews (2002)
Matthews compares the Green Man’s cyclical death and rebirth to the Sheela-na-gig’s simultaneous embodiment of birth and decay, situating both within an archetypal framework of liminality and renewal.
Expanded Annotated Bibliography: Folklore, Gender, and Ecology Studies
The Wild Man: Medieval Myth and Symbolism – Timothy Husband (1980)
A study of the “wild man” motif in medieval art, exploring cultural anxieties about untamed masculinity, sexuality, and civilisation — themes resonant with both the Green Man and Sheela-na-gig.
The Myth of the Eternal Return – Mircea Eliade (1954)
Examines cyclical time and ritual renewal in archaic societies. Offers theoretical grounding for understanding why figures like the Green Man and Sheela-na-gig persisted as mediators of cyclical renewal and threshold rites.
The Great Mother: An Analysis of the Archetype – Erich Neumann (1955)
Explores the feminine archetype in its dual aspects of life-giving and devouring. Illuminates Sheela-na-gig as an image embodying both protective and destructive power.
Women Who Run With the Wolves – Clarissa Pinkola Estés (1992)
Though not specifically about medieval carvings, Estés’ analysis of wild feminine archetypes helps contextualise Sheela-na-gig within a lineage of untamed female power.
Ecology, Community and Lifestyle – Arne Naess (1989)
Foundational text of deep ecology, arguing for an ecological self beyond human dominance. Provides philosophical context for interpreting the Green Man as an ecological archetype rather than mere decorative motif.
The Gendered Object – Pat Kirkham (ed.) (1996)
A collection exploring how objects and images carry gendered meanings. Offers tools for analysing how the Green Man and Sheela-na-gig both reflect and shape cultural constructions of masculinity and femininity.
The Sacred and the Profane – Mircea Eliade (1957)
Discusses how religious architecture marks thresholds between sacred and profane, directly relevant to why both figures often appear over doorways and liminal spaces.
No comments:
Post a Comment